Body Snatched By Medical Students
Newport, Vermont
December 11, 1895

   
       
 

"The people throughout this section and in adjacent New Hampshire towns are greatly excited over the grave robbery here on Friday night, and  today's developments have added fuel to the flames of sentiment.

The arrest of J.P. Gifford and the hold of him in $2000 [bond], followed by the arrest of John O'Donnell at Strafford tonight, in no means allayed the interest in the case, and startling revelations are expected shortly. The authorities are now searching for evidence which will warrant the arrest of a third man.

That Joseph M. was murdered, and that his body was removed from its grave to prevent an autopsy. [This] belief is gaining ground.

On the day before Thanksgiving, Joseph M. was found hanging from a tree near his home, and it was considered a case of suicide. It is now asserted that when the body was found the strap around the neck was so loose that a hand could be pushed inside it, and that the neck had not the mark that would have been made had the man been choked to death by it, and further, that an imprint of fingers was noticeable upon the neck.

The body is said to have stood as though it was stiff before the strap was put around the neck, and it is surmised by some that the man was dead before he was placed by the tree.

A bottle that Joseph M. was known to have had medicine in was found not far from his home, and this is said to have been called for by a member of his family, and is now missing. Poison is assumed by some to have been in this bottle.

State Attorney Enwright and Sheriff Spofford have been working all day here and in Hanover, but they are preserving the strictest secrecy in the matter.

This afternoon Gifford was arraigned in court. He pleaded not guilty to the charge of body snatching, and was bound over to $2000 to the grand jury. Many members of the Dartmouth faculty were present in the hearing, and they promptly furnished bail, Gifford returning to Hanover tonight. He would say nothing in regard to the case.

O'Donnell, who was arrested tonight at Strafford, will be given a hearing tomorrow. He has been there for the past few days during the medical college vacation.

S.D. Snow, the student who was at first thought to be implicated, has proved to authorities that he had no connection with the case.

The body was found concealed in Hanover this afternoon by State Attorney Enwright. It will probably be again buried in the family lot from where it was stolen, although in view of the sensational reports current, an autopsy may be performed.

The two arrested are said to have been brought about through information by Dr. Bowles, proprietor of the Newton Inn, and in the event of a conviction he is likely to claim the $1000 reward offered by the selectmen.

On Friday night, when it was believed the grave was robbed, Gifford, O'Donnell, Snow and another medical student, served as waiters at the banquet of the Alpha Delta Phi society in the inn.

After the feast the students started to walk to Hanover, leaving the hotel about 1 a.m. At 2 they were overtaken on the road by fraternity men, who were being driven home in a coach.

It is said that at 3 O'Donnell returned to the hotel stable and sought to hire a horse and wagon, stating to the man in charge that his companions had become intoxicated, and that he wanted to get them home to Hanover.

A large horse was hitched into the express wagon used in conveying the mails, and O'Donnell drove off, returning the rig in an hour.

The hoof prints on the road corresponded with those of the animal driven, and the wheel tracks are also the same distance apart, being easily distinguished, as they are narrower than those of an ordinary carriage.

Gifford belongs in West Randolph, VT, is a graduate of Dartmouth of the class of '94, and entered the medical school last fall. Snow's from Washington, D.C., and O'Donnell from Strafford. All are highly connected and very popular among their classmates and the towns-people of Hanover."
...
"On December 18, 1896, John P. Gifford and Jack MacDonald, [both] Dartmouth medical students, in the Windsor County, VT, superior court, pleaded guilty to the charge of body snatching, and were fined $2000 and $1500 respectively.

Gifford settled promptly, and MacDonald rests in jail. Friends will undoubtedly raise money for payment of his fine. Both were popular at Dartmouth. Gifford graduated from the medical college with valedictory honors last month."

   
       
 

   
       
 

Return To Witch Stories

   
       
     
 

Home     Disclaimer     Contact     Site Map

 
     
 

Copyright © 2009 CelebrateBoston.com - All Rights Reserved